That said, Mantha is on this list not because he would make a bad signing for the Red Wings. He’s one player I would endorse returning to Detroit because he could bring in some serious depth scoring, especially after this past season. Although he didn’t seem to be as physical this year while in Washington, that changed in Vegas, but my concern with Mantha has to do with his potential contract length.

He played well enough this season to justify more than just a “prove it” deal, and there is also a good chance he signs on for another two or three seasons. It’s ironic because, before the All-Star Break, there was a different narrative going on with Mantha, who had 23 points and 15 goals in his first 43 contests.

But he picked up his play after the All-Star Break with 21 points and eight goals in 31 outings, catapulting his points per game from 0.534 per to 0.677 per. Before the All-Star Break, Mantha may have been on pace to sign a modest, one-year deal, but that’s not quite the case now, and he could get in the way of a high-end prospect in Detroit if he signed a multi-year contract.

Viktor Arvidsson, Los Angeles Kings

Whether he sticks with the Los Angeles Kings or goes elsewhere, someone will get a phenomenal veteran in Viktor Arvidsson. He’s been such a good player in this league that, as with Anthony Mantha, not a single fan should be too disappointed if Arvidsson ended up with the Red Wings.

Sure, he saw time in just 18 games this season, but he also made them count with 15 points and six goals. He was still playing well in the defensive zone, inconveniencing opponents either by preventing shots from reaching the net with 18 blocks or poking the puck away with his stick. The latter means Arvidsson would be one of those forwards who would also give the Red Wings much-needed assistance in the defensive zone.

But for me, the problem is this: He came across as injury-prone this past season, and a team on the verge of ending a playoff drought cannot afford to invest in a high-risk player regardless of the rewards.

It would be one thing if Arvidsson returned and stayed healthy following a 60-game layoff because of a back operation. But he instead almost immediately returned to injured reserve after playing in just a handful of games before he finally got healthy.

Anthony Beauvillier, Nashville Predators

There is always that one player in free agency who you think could thrive off of a fresh start, and I’m not talking about two trades that player was part of in a single season here. Instead, someone like Anthony Beauvillier could use a fresh start and a full season, as doing so means he may return to the serviceable player he was and one who received top and middle-six minutes.

Between 2017-18 and 2022-23, Beauvillier put up 18 or more goals in a season four different times, he was rather physical, and he also put up a solid 20 game-winning goals in that span. The 2023-24 season saw Beauvillier as a player at crossroads, in which he finished the year with 17 points and five goals in 60 contests, and there wasn’t a single area of his game that was enticing.

While landing with the right team could turn around Beauvillier’s fortunes, he is, like Viktor Arvidsson, too much of a risk for the Red Wings this season. Steve Yzerman must sign surefire forwards, and there is nothing certain about a player who, even following his age-26 season, could already be seeing his career jet south.

If Yzerman were to take a chance on a high-risk forward in free agency between Beauvillier and Arvidsson, he would be better off with the latter. But ideally, Yzerman would roll with someone at a reasonable price who can stay healthy and add another layer of production.